Security deposit laws in New York: limits, deductions, and returns
Paralegal review is rolling out across guides — we'll add a co-byline here once this guide has been reviewed by a licensed paralegal. See our editorial standards.
In New York, landlords can collect up to one month's rent (housing stability and tenant protection act of 2019) as a security deposit and must return it (with an itemized list of any deductions) within 14 days of move-out. Deductions are limited to unpaid rent and actual damage beyond normal wear and tear.
Want answers about your lease, not just general rules?
Upload your lease and we'll grade it, summarize it, and flag the exact clauses that affect you — free, 30 seconds.
The specific terms of your lease may change how these rules apply to you. If you want to know exactly what your lease says — escalation clauses, termination penalties, deposit rules — you can upload your lease for a free AI analysis and get a plain-English breakdown.
Maximum security deposit in New York
The maximum deposit a New York landlord can charge is one month's rent (housing stability and tenant protection act of 2019). Charging more than this is generally illegal, and you may be entitled to recover the excess plus penalties under NY Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.; § 226-c (notice); § 7-108 (deposits).
This limit usually includes "last month's rent" if it's collected upfront and not strictly applied to the final month — courts often treat it as part of the deposit. The same is often true of "move-in fees," "key deposits," and similar charges that walk and quack like a deposit.
When and how the deposit must be returned
After you move out and provide a forwarding address in writing, your landlord has 14 days to either return the full deposit or send an itemized list of deductions along with the remaining balance.
If the landlord misses this deadline, many states (including the rules under NY Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.; § 226-c (notice); § 7-108 (deposits)) allow the tenant to recover the full deposit plus damages — sometimes double or triple the amount wrongfully withheld. The deadline is one of the few hard, bright-line rules in landlord-tenant law; judges enforce it strictly.
You moved out of a Hell's Kitchen studio on June 1 and gave a forwarding address. Under General Obligations Law §7-108 (amended 2019), the landlord has 14 days to return your deposit with an itemized statement. Deposits are capped at 1 month's rent statewide. If they miss the 14-day deadline, they forfeit the right to make ANY deductions — you get the full amount back.
What a landlord can deduct
- Unpaid rent owed at move-out (including rent that accrued because you broke the lease early).
- Cost to repair damage caused by you, your guests, or your pets — beyond normal wear and tear.
- Unpaid late fees or other charges allowed by the lease.
- Cleaning costs if the unit is left substantially dirtier than when you moved in.
What is NOT a legal deduction
- Normal wear and tear — faded paint, lightly worn carpet in traffic areas, small nail holes from hanging pictures.
- Repairs to fix age-related deterioration (e.g., re-painting after 5 years of occupancy, replacing carpet older than its useful life).
- Cleaning charges if the unit was professionally cleaned at move-in and is returned in similar condition.
- "Standard" cleaning, carpet, or paint fees automatically deducted without itemization (these are often successfully challenged).
Three small nail holes from hanging picture frames = normal wear and tear, NOT deductible. A 6-inch hole from a doorknob slamming through drywall = damage, deductible at the cost of the patch and paint touch-up. Light traffic patterns on a 4-year-old carpet = wear and tear. A red wine stain the size of a dinner plate = damage. The legal test is whether the wear is from ordinary, reasonable use over time.
New York-specific rules to know
- Maximum deposit: One month's rent (Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019).
- Return deadline: 14 days after move-out.
- Late-fee cap (lease related): Greater of $50 or 5% of monthly rent.
- Governing statute: NY Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.; § 226-c (notice); § 7-108 (deposits).
- HSTPA capped statewide security deposits at 1 month's rent — applies to ALL rentals, regulated or not.
- The 14-day return deadline is strict: missing it forfeits the landlord's right to retain any portion (General Obligations Law §7-108(1-a)(e)).
- Landlords must offer both a move-in AND a move-out inspection — failure to offer either limits the deductions they can claim.
The deposit-return timeline at a glance
- 1Move-out day
Return keys, complete walk-through with landlord if possible, take photos and video of every room.
- 2Forwarding address sent
Email + certified mail. This is the moment the 14 days clock starts in New York.
- 3Landlord inspects
Landlord assesses damage vs. wear and tear, gets repair estimates, prepares itemization.
- 4Deadline runs
By the end of 14 days, the landlord must send either (a) full refund or (b) refund + itemized deductions.
- 5If nothing arrives
Send a written demand letter citing the statute and the missed deadline. Give 7–14 days to respond.
- 6Small claims court
File for the deposit + statutory penalties. Bring your photos, the lease, the forwarding-address proof, and the demand letter.
How to maximize your refund
- Take dated, well-lit photos of every room at move-in AND move-out — every wall, every appliance, every floor.
- Complete the move-in inspection checklist in writing — note every existing scratch, stain, and defect.
- Give written notice of your forwarding address — this starts the return clock.
- Request a pre-move-out inspection so you can fix issues before keys are returned.
- Clean thoroughly: appliances inside and out, baseboards, inside cabinets, behind toilets, oven racks, fridge coils.
- Don't forget non-obvious spots landlords specifically check: window tracks, blinds, light fixtures, dryer lint trap, drip pans.
Not sure whether your own lease has a clause like this? Paste it into the free checker — you'll see exactly which of the 47 checks it trips.
Recent legislation that affects you
Capped deposits at 1 month, shortened return window to 14 days, and forfeits deduction rights if the landlord misses the deadline.
Where to file a claim or complaint
Typical timeline: AG complaints often prompt landlord response within 30–60 days; small claims hearing typically 30–60 days post-filing.
Common mistakes renters make
Why it matters: In New York, the 14 days return clock typically only starts when the landlord has your address in writing. No address means the deadline never begins to run — and tenants who waited "for the landlord to ask" often wait forever.
How to avoid it: Send the forwarding address by both email and certified mail on move-out day. Keep the green card / delivery receipt.
Why it matters: Without a written record of pre-existing damage, the landlord can charge you at move-out for the previous tenant's scuffs, stains, and broken blinds. It's nearly impossible to disprove later.
How to avoid it: Within 24 hours of getting the keys, photograph everything, fill out the inspection form, and email a copy to the landlord. Get a reply confirming receipt.
Why it matters: Flat-rate deductions like "carpet cleaning: $250" or "paint: $400" applied to every tenant regardless of condition are often illegal. Many New York judges throw them out.
How to avoid it: If you cleaned the unit and the carpets are in normal condition, dispute the deduction in writing and demand itemized receipts for actual costs incurred.
Why it matters: The longer you wait, the harder it gets to enforce. Some states require you to act within a set window to claim statutory penalties.
How to avoid it: The day after the 14 days deadline passes, send the demand letter. The clock should not slip a single week.
Why it matters: Small claims filing fees are usually under $100, you don't need a lawyer, and landlords often settle the moment they're served. The deposit + statutory damages can be thousands of dollars.
How to avoid it: Walk into your local small claims court (or check its website). Filing takes about 30 minutes once you have the demand letter and evidence ready.
What to do if your deposit isn't returned
- Send a formal demand letter by certified mail citing NY Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.; § 226-c (notice); § 7-108 (deposits) and the 14 days deadline.
- File in small claims court — most states allow tenants to recover the deposit plus statutory penalties.
- Many states allow recovery of double or triple damages for bad-faith withholding.
- Contact your state attorney general's office if the landlord owns multiple properties and has a pattern of violations.
- If the deposit dispute is connected to a landlord notice to end the lease, retaliation rules may add to your claim.
Tenant resources in this state
Small claims limit: **$10,000 in NYC; $5,000 in city courts; $3,000 in town/village courts**. Filing in small claims court is usually the fastest, cheapest way to recover a wrongfully withheld deposit or contest broken-lease charges.
- NY State Division of Housing & Community Renewal (DHCR)
Rent regulation, rent overcharge complaints, deposit disputes
- NY Attorney General — Tenant Rights
Landlord harassment, illegal evictions, security deposit fraud
- NYC Housing Court Answers
Free housing court navigation for NYC tenants
Local considerations across New York
Rules under New York law apply statewide, but how they play out on the ground varies by city. Renters in New York City, Buffalo, and Rochester run into the same statute language with very different landlord behavior — larger complex operators in New York City tend to follow the letter of the rule, while smaller owner-landlords in Buffalo more often improvise. Either way, the New York statute is what a court applies if the dispute escalates.
- New York City: high-volume rental market, more corporate leases with templated clauses — most of what gets challenged is over-broad language, not missing terms. If you're in New York City, upload your lease for a free New York scan before you sign.
- Buffalo: mid-size market where individual landlords and small property managers dominate — informal promises are common and rarely enforceable, so get everything in writing.
- Rochester: growing rental demand often pushes landlords to test the edges of New York law on rent, fees, and entry — knowing the statute by number (New York follows the framework we cite above) is the fastest way to push back.
Get a free New York lease scan before you decide
Most New York disputes on this topic start with a lease clause the renter didn't fully read. Before you sign, negotiate, or push back, upload your lease for a free New York scan — we run a free AI scan on every clause and flag anything that goes further than New York law allows, in seconds, no account required.
- Upload the lease for a free New York scan — we highlight risky clauses line by line.
- Or upload the clause you're worried about for a free clause-level analysis.
- Every free AI scan is anonymous — no email, no account, no payment for the initial report.
- Upload your lease and get a free analysis in under 60 seconds, before you sign anything in New York.
- Prefer to explore first? Try the sample New York report to see exactly what a free scan looks like.
Frequently asked questions
How much can a landlord charge for a security deposit in New York?
Up to one month's rent (housing stability and tenant protection act of 2019). Anything over that limit is generally not enforceable under NY Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.; § 226-c (notice); § 7-108 (deposits).
How long does a landlord have to return my deposit?
14 days after move-out, in New York. The clock typically starts when you provide a forwarding address in writing.
What counts as 'normal wear and tear'?
Wear that naturally results from ordinary use: minor scuffs on walls, light carpet wear in traffic areas, faded paint, loose grout. Tenants are not responsible for these.
Can my landlord keep my deposit for cleaning?
Only if the unit is left substantially dirtier than it was at move-in, and only for the actual reasonable cost. Routine cleaning between tenants is the landlord's expense, not yours.
What if my landlord ignores my demand letter?
File a claim in small claims court — the filing fee is usually under $100 and you do not need a lawyer. Many New York courts will award the deposit plus statutory damages for bad-faith withholding.
Still unsure how these rules apply to your specific lease? Run the free 47-point check — it flags the exact clauses that affect you in about 30 seconds. Landlords and legal-aid orgs can grade leases in bulk.
Sources & further reading
This guide is based on the following primary sources. Statutes change — always confirm against the current text before acting.
- New York statute: NY Real Prop. Law § 220 et seq.; § 226-c (notice); § 7-108 (deposits)
Opens an official-source search (New York legislature / .gov) for the citation above.
- HUD tenant rights: U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development — state tenant rights
Not sure how your lease applies?
Upload your lease and LeaseWise will flag the exact clauses that affect your rights — early termination, rent escalators, deposit rules, and more — in under a minute.
Managing a portfolio or advising tenants at scale? The 47-check LeaseScore bulk analyzer grades every lease in a bundle.
Common clauses worth checking
These are the specific clauses tied to security deposit laws — what they mean, when they're standard, and when to push back.
- Carpet cleaning feeCharging tenants for routine carpet cleaning is illegal in most states. Landlords can only deduct for damage beyond normal wear and tear, not for getting the unit ready for the next tenant.
- Non-refundable cleaning feeLegal in some states (TX, FL, GA), illegal in others (CA, MA — any 'deposit' must be refundable). Where legal, $200–$400 is the normal range for a 1–2 bedroom; more than that is a soft red flag.
- 3-month security depositIllegal in most states. The vast majority cap security deposits at 1–2 months' rent. Three months almost certainly violates your state's deposit cap.
- Non-refundable holding depositA non-refundable holding deposit (often $200–$500) holds the unit while you complete paperwork. You lose it if you back out — read carefully.
More New York guides
General information, not legal advice. The LeaseWise editorial team reviews this content for clarity and accuracy against current statutes, but editorial review does not create an attorney-client relationship and is not a substitute for legal advice. Landlord-tenant law changes frequently and local ordinances may add stricter rules. State law data on this page was last reviewed and is reviewed and updated once per year. Verify any decision that affects your tenancy with a licensed attorney or your state housing agency before acting.
