Tenant pays for after-hours calls deemed non-emergency

Reviewed by Marcus A. Hall, Founder
Worth a closer look
Legal in most places, but pushy — try to negotiate.
Quick answer

Charging for non-emergency after-hours calls is fair — but 'emergency' needs clear definition. Burst pipes = yes; dripping faucet = no.

Is this clause in your lease?

Upload your lease and we'll flag this clause (and every other red flag) in 30 seconds — free.

What it actually means

After-hours service calls cost landlords extra. If you call at 2am for a minor issue, paying a fee is reasonable.

The risk: landlords may retroactively call your emergency 'non-emergency' to charge you. Get the definition in writing.

What it looks like in a lease

"If Tenant requests after-hours service for an issue deemed non-emergency, Tenant shall pay the service call fee."

What to watch for

  • Definition of emergency
  • Who decides
  • Fee amount

How to negotiate it

'Please define emergency explicitly: flood, fire, no heat in winter, gas leak.'

When it crosses into a red flag

  • Landlord decides retroactively
  • Fee exceeds $200

Frequently asked questions

What counts as an emergency?

Typically: no heat in winter, flooding, gas leak, break-in, fire damage. A clogged toilet at 3am is borderline.

Related clauses

General information, not legal advice. Clauses are interpreted differently across states and courts. For a binding interpretation of your specific lease, consult a licensed attorney in your state.

Chat with VincentTenant-rights AI